Butter Chicken

RESTAURANT QAULITY!! You’ll never buy a butter chicken again ๐Ÿ™‚

Submitted by Anon

Butter Chicken

RESTAURANT QAULITY!! You'll never buy a butter chicken again ๐Ÿ™‚
No ratings yet
Serving: 4
Prep Time 10 mins
Cook Time 5 hrs
Total Time 5 hrs 10 mins

Ingredients
 

  • 1 tablespoon olive oil
  • 4 cloves garlic, crushed
  • 1 onion, diced
  • 1 (420ml/14-ounce) can light coconut milk
  • 1 (175ml/6-ounce) can tomato paste
  • 2 tablespoons whole wheat flour
  • 2 teaspoons garam masala
  • 1 teaspoon curry powder
  • 1/2 teaspoon chili powder, or more, to taste
  • 1/2 teaspoon ginger powder
  • Salt and freshly ground black pepper, to taste
  • 1kg boneless, skinless chicken breasts, cut into 2-inch pieces
  • 2 tablespoons chopped fresh cilantro leaves (coriander)

Instructions
 

  • Heat olive oil in a pan over medium high heat.
  • Add garlic and onion, and cook, stirring for 2-3 minutes.
  • Stir in coconut milk, tomato paste, flour, garam masala, curry powder, chili powder and ginger powder until well combined and slightly thickened, about 1-2 minutes
  • Add salt and pepper, to taste.
  • Place chicken into slow cooker.
  • Add the sauce and combine.
  • Cover and cook on low heat for 5 hours.
  • Add the cilantro in the last hour

Note

  • Optional ... the photo of the recipe above has 300ml of cooking cream stirred through in the last half hour before serving for a creamy consistency.
  • Photo updated at request of recipe submitter
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

92 thoughts on “Butter Chicken”

  1. I made this for the family with a 4 year old and 2.5 year.old. they don’t mind Spicey food and regularly eat butter chicken. I.made this with the half recommended amount of chilli (so 1/4 tsp). It still packed quite a punch! Perhaps try this with 1/8 tsp if making for younger members then increase chilli next time til youbat happy with volume.

  2. LOVE LOVE LOVED this recipe!!
    I adore butter chicken but I’ve always paid nearly $15 a dish for take away.
    I was able to make this entire recipe for less than that and it tasted just like the real thing!

    I added 300ml of cooking cream in the last hour just because I like it creamy and to drop the heat level a little bit
    And I skipped the cilantro as I don’t like it

    But I KNOW this recipe is going to be a weekly staple in my house now ๐Ÿ™‚

    Thanks for sharing xx

  3. Too spicy. Also it waa nice but just felt like it was missing something. I’d say it’s definitely missing butter.

  4. This is so yummy. I used a small can of coconut cream and a small UHT of lite evaporated milk and then some coconut essence just to lower the fat a little – and I will add less curry powder as we use keens and my guys found it too spicy!! But it was the best tasting recipe ever and I’ve been searching for a great butter chicken recipe forever!!

  5. I made this today and it turned out great.

    I added some cream 1 hour before serving, and also added a few tablespoons of cashew butter and brown sugar to sweeten it up a bit as I found it a bit bland when I tasted it. But after adding these few things it was very tasty!

    I served it with some saffron rice also which made the whole dish super yummy.

  6. Love this!
    So first time ever cooking with a slow cooker. I picked this recipe and it did not disappoint everyone in my family agrees this is better then store brought jars.

    โ€ข I left out the coriander
    โ€ข and left out the chilli (for my toddler)

    โ€ข added about 150-200ml cream half an hour before serving.

    Turned out great:)

  7. Just had this for dinner, put it on for 5 hours followed the instructions and it tastes absolutely horrible ๐Ÿ˜ข๐Ÿ˜ข I have no idea what went wrong but I’m so disappointed!!

  8. So disappointed, followed the recipe perfectly and this tasted absolutely nothing like butter chicken and was fairly bland. I’d seen everyone talk about it so much and I was so excited to try it but, it was a complete let down.

    Does anyone know if any of the other butter chicken recipes are better?

  9. Did anyone actually pre brown things in a pan? Cause I find it so much easier to skip this and throw it all in the sc ๐Ÿ™‚

  10. My hubby, son and I loved this butter chicken recipe. I didn’t add the coriander because I don’t like it. Will definitely be making again and again. Thankyou for sharing๐Ÿ˜€๐Ÿ‘

  11. My kids made this for dinner while I was at work, so not sure if they added & measured everything correctly lol, but we all found it delish! Will definately add the cream in next time ๐Ÿ™‚

  12. This recipe is awesome although I reduced the chilli to 1/8 tsp and it still had some heat in it (too much for the kids). I also added about 100mls of cream about 45 minutes before serving. Hubby couldn’t believe it had come out of the slow cooker, super yum!!!!

  13. Colleen Arnott

    I made this today. I used chicken thighs and also added the cream like Pauline an hour before serving. It was absolutely delicious…(although I’d have to say it doesn’t taste much like the butter chicken we get from our local Indian restaurant)

  14. Really nice but needed the cream at the end. We didn’t not find it spicy at all. I added the chilli as per the recipe and my 7 month old, 2 year old and 3 year old all loved it. It was a little mild for me.

  15. Not quite restaurant quality although had lots of flavour and mild heat …….the fussy eater who says everything is too spicy enjoyed the dish. I cooked this following the recipe and found it a bit to runny when finished.
    On the ease to create scale I rate this 7/10

  16. OK iv seen everyone comment about and share this recipe saying its amazing I followed the recipe and found it has way to much tomato paste all I can taste is tomato dosent taste pike butter chicken unless its just me but for next time I know not so much tomato paste other wise great recipe ๐Ÿ™‚

  17. do you think this would work in a dump bag? If so would you pre-cook onion and garlic and thicken the sauce first? Thank you for your advice.

  18. Butter chicken has been a regular dish in our house I usually buy the premade dishes from Woolworths or Coles. I finally tried out this recipe that was going around the page and it did not disappoint. Only changes I made was to double the spices, left out the coriander (not a fan) and added 300ml cooking cream in the last 30mins definitely will be making it like this from now on ๐Ÿ˜Š๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿป

  19. If adding the cream at the end do you still add the coconut cream with all the other ingredients?
    Also what kind of curry powder do you use? Keens?

  20. Made this tonight, OMG!!! Hubby and I are so happy will be making this at least once a week!!!! Tried few butter chickens and never was nice until now!!! Yum!!!

  21. This is a menu regular in our house! Feeding a toddler so i leave out the chilli and still delicious. Thanks for such a great easy delicious recipe Pauline.

  22. Marilyn Whitley

    Definitely a family favourite I halve the chilli piwder quantity and I always put a good squirt of tomato sauce in as well, It just seems to enhance and give depth the flavour.

  23. I made this a few nights ago, oh man it was the best butter chicken I’ve ever had. Hubby and miss nearly 2 both loved it and hubby went for 2nds ๐Ÿ˜… Keens curry powder was enough for us though no chilli required lol

  24. This was absolutely devine….. Invited my mum and dad for dinner and it was a hit and have also sign mum up to this page….. Will definitely be making again… I also added cooking cream at the end and I will up the amount of chilli also….

  25. Interesting, this was tasting great but the addition of cream (less than stated) reduced the richness of the taste. I tried another recipe last time & will probably revert, but might try this again without the cream!

  26. This recipe is absolutely divine! I left out the cilantro and added some thickened cream just before serving this with rice. The whole family loved this and happily licked their plates clean. An extra bonus with this recipe is I no longer need to buy store bought jars for butter chicken #winning ๐Ÿ™‚ Thanks so much for sharing this with us ๐Ÿ˜Š

  27. Such a delicious recipe!! I changed it up a little by mixing chicken thighs and chicken breasts, I use chili and ginger paste, plus I blend the sauce with a stick blender. I then add cardamonm pods cook for 5 mins then take them out before adding the sauce and chicken to the slow cooker.

  28. Never had butter chicken before but made it tonight and had empty plates it was lovely
    I used diced chicken breast instead of thigh
    Thank you for the recipe will definitely be making it again

  29. Decent curry but not like the proper butter chicken at an Indian restaurant.
    Added cream at the end for the kids to make it milder for them. Also added a cup of frozen peas last 5 min.

  30. Made this today. Added a T of stevia just to sweeten it for the kids (so it was a bit more like takeout) and all plates were cleaned. Served with steamed veggies, rice and garlic naans. Very tasty.

  31. Love this recipe. I add a little bit more cream at the end as my little girl doesnโ€™t like it too spicy, but I donโ€™t think it needs messed with in any way

  32. First time making and eating Butter Chicken. This recipe worked for my whole Family. I tried to keep to the published Recipe but found that I had to add a Tbl of brown sugar and, as suggested by the poster, about 300ml of cooking cream. This made the dish lush and smooth, it also mellowed the heat. My Wife, who doesn’t like spicy heat at all, added some more cream to her dish and eat it all. My Son who likes spice and heat, lapped it all up. All in All a great success and I will do it again. Thank you for the Recipe.

  33. Shannon Anderson

    Havenโ€™t had much much luck with other butter chicken recipes or jar/packet versions. My daughter, who loved butter chicken, has always thought they were just โ€œokayโ€ but this recipe was a hit for the whole family.

  34. Oh my wow ๐Ÿ˜๐Ÿคค made this for first time & was so yum!!! I followed recipe & was just right for my family!! There is enough left over for tomorrow or I’ll freeze for later!! Thank you for sharing a great recipe ๐Ÿ˜Š

  35. I cooked Butter Chicken for tea tonight . All I can say is OMG ….. absolutely delicious ๐Ÿ˜‹
    I will definitely be making this again .
    It was a lil spicy ….. but it was perfect.
    Hubby loved it

  36. Shelley Skinner

    Very yummy! Nice and creamy, definitely needed the extra cream in the last half hour. I did less chilli powder for the kids, but would put it all in if it were just me eating it, and would add extra curry powder and tomato paste if it were just me also. I added steamed veggies to the bowls (carrot, broccolli and capsicum). It was a hit with the kids! Great recipe x

  37. I’ve cooked this a few times in the past month I enjoy it so much. I do not like and cannot tolerate spicy hot food, particularly many Indian dishes, so leaving out the chili is all I do and I still love the taste this brings. For me the cream and coriander near the end are a must.

  38. Such a tasty meal & a no fuss recipe. Used a little less tomato paste to suit our taste. This will be on regular rotation!

  39. Sarah Anderson

    Made a few small changes but the whole family absolutely loved this recipe! I purรฉed the onion with a little sauce before I put the chicken so it was nice and smooth. Used coconut cream instead of milk just because itโ€™s what was in the cupboard but it made it nice and creamy so didnโ€™t need to add the flour. I also left out the chilli but decided afterwards it needed a little something extra so added a few teaspoons of korma paste. It was AMAZING! Even better the next day.

  40. Margaret McCluskey

    I made this for dinner tonight, everyone loved it, my husband even said it was the best chicken dish I had ever made. (Weโ€™ve been married 45years) ๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘

  41. I will never buy butter chicken again!!!
    This was so easy to do and having 4 very fussy eaters go back for seconds is an amazing feeling.
    If there was 10 stars… I’d be hitting every single one of them

  42. I made this tonight. I used 1.5 x the spices needed and I didnโ€™t add the cream at the end. I bought the cream ready to use but after taste testing I thought it was great and didnโ€™t want to dull the flavour with the cream. We all really really enjoyed this dish. Very flavoursome and much better than the jars and packets. Will definitely make it again ๐Ÿ™‚

  43. I made this last night and it is now on the list of permanent recipes for our family! It was awesome and really hit the spot as I love Indian but with family allergies I needed a recipe with no nuts that still had the taste – this did indeed!
    I didnโ€™t quite have enough tomato paste (just under) but it was delicious anyway! I think I will avoid cream as I had to limit chilli because of the children. Fantastic dish & easy to make!

  44. My son is allergic to coconut, but I would love to try this recipe. Do you think I could substitute the coconut milk with evaporated milk or something else? Thanks in advance!

  45. Before Iโ€™d even sat down at the table I heard my fussy husband say โ€œthis curry is awesome!โ€ I blended the onion and garlic in my NutriBullet before cooking in the pan with the tomato paste and spices. I also added turmeric and cumin powder. I didnโ€™t add the coconut milk or cream until the very end as I donโ€™t like to add flour to my curry sauces. After taking some curry out to purรฉe for my 8mo (who loved it!) I added some chicken stock powder and brown sugar. I served with steamed rice , broccoli , extra chilli for me, some natural yoghurt and homemade flat bread. Will definitely make again!

  46. Made this today for the first time and whilst it was very nice, it was missing something. I added a spoon of brown sugar but it possibly needed more and I may try more tomato paste next time. My partner liked it but said it just wasnโ€™t as rich as a restaurant butter chicken. Still a tasty and easy dinner though.

  47. Made this tonight for my family, and everyone devoured it!
    A few variations; I doubled the spices in the recipe, used coconut cream instead of coconut milk, and added about a teaspoon of sugar. I also added about 150ml cream in the last 30 mins of cooking.

  48. Just made this today and it was so delicious even my fussy 8year old loved it I used plain flour and left out the chilli, I also used passata and left out the cilantro, and when it had half hour left i put creme fraiche

  49. Made this at the weekend , was away at our static holiday home , goes without saying I have a slow cooker there as well as at home !! Thought I would give this recipe a try , never had butter chicken before but it was so simple and incredibly tasty , put it on in the morning and was able to go off and make the most of our time away , fabulous !!

  50. Jacqui Burton

    Made this for our family. Delicious! Everyone enjoyed it. I had some space in my large slow cooker (using oven bags) so I made a version with no chicken, I substituted a can of drained chick peas, and a smallish sweet potato cut into about 2cm cubes, the rest was the same ingredients (no cream).

  51. Louise UK ๐Ÿ‡ฌ๐Ÿ‡ง

    Healthy & Tasty!
    Quick to throw together on my lunch break & was ready for the family in the evening. Swirled a tiny bit of single cream through before serving.
    Next time I might experiment with adding spinach before serving plus use fresh ginger.

  52. Made this in the hopes it was almost as good as restaurant quality. Yum! We had to add 2 tablespoons brown sugar as it was a bit tart even though we added the cream. Highly recommend! Definitely saves us a lot of $$ as indian takeaway can be pricey to get regularly. My boys 4 and 8 lovvveed it! Thankyou for another winner! This has been added to our rotation. All I need to learn now is how to make palak paneer, malai kofta and garlic naan ! Lol

  53. This is as good as any Resturant Butter Chicken. Some like it spicy but I have one child that doesn’t like spicy so I just put a dash of cooking cream in his bowl.

  54. Just made this recipe, WOW I’m impressed. No more buying it 4 this house. Can’t believe how good it is with only a few ingredients. Thanx Paulene 4 your great recipes

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Scroll to Top