Cookie Monster Fudge


December 15, 2015

Cookie Monster Fudge 5 0 5 2
  • Prep: 5 mins
  • Cook: 45 mins
  • 5 mins

    45 mins

    50 mins

  • Yields: 24 pieces


1 x 340g bag wilton blue candy melts

1/2 cup white chocolate

1 can sweetened condensed milk

Few drops of blue food colour

1 cup mini oreos (save some for topping)

1 cup broken up choc chip cookies (save some for topping)

Sugar eyes for decoration


1Put everything in slow cooker (except cookies and eyes)

2Cook on low with lid off for approx 45 min stirring every 10-15 min (5.5L slow cooker)

3Mix cookies into fudge during last 5 mins of cooking time

4Poor into 28x19cm tray and top with more cookies and eyes!

5Set in fridge for 3-4 hours

6White chocolate can over cook easily so ensure you stir your fudge every 10-15 minutes. Your fudge is ready when it gets a bit crusty like on top.

Submitted by Nicky Rothenberger


2 Reviews


January 12, 2018

Easy to make
I just used all white chocolate as I couldn’t find the Wilton candy melts can’t wait to eat some


December 21, 2017

I loved it very easy to make. Kids loved it along with the parents. Only thing I would change is instead of saying one “bag of Wilton blue candy melts” please say so many grams or cups of blue choc melts for anyone that can’t find the bags and it will give them an idea of size they need. Other then that I loved loved loved this.

All fields are required to submit a review.

Please note that all comments are held in moderation and manually approved. It may be several minutes until you see yours. Please Do Not resubmit your comment during this time.